September 11, 2018 Content & Email Marketing

Despite the wide array of website tracking tools and data collection methods marketers have at their disposal, the average website conversion rate is just 2.35%. This is a troubling statistic, especially considering that conversions — whether they’re online leads, inbound calls, subscribers, eCommerce customers, event registrants, or donors — are the primary goal of any website. Missed conversions represent missed revenue.

So, what can you do to raise your website conversion rates? In a recent webinar with Andy Crestodina, CMO of Orbit Media Studios, entitled Your 60-Minute Masterclass: Website Conversion Optimization, we presented the following list of best practices.

1. Separate Your Website into Sales Pages and Content Marketing Pages

When building your site, you’ll want to target two main types of visitors: informational and transactional.

Informational visitors (who make up the majority) are simply looking for answers to their questions — they don’t intend to make a purchase. In order to appeal to these visitors, you’ll need to write broad, top-of-the-funnel content to satisfy their curiosity and increase awareness of your product or service. Perhaps the best way to accomplish this is with a “blog” or “resources library” website page. Since these visitors are so far up the funnel, you’ll need to offer low-commitment call-to-actions like “subscribe.”

Transactional visitors are coming to your website with purchasing intent. To capture conversions from these users, you’ll need to answer their pre-purchase questions, provide evidence about the value your product or service, and offer a compelling call-to-action. This is best accomplished on product or service pages.

These tips focus on appealing to transactional website visitors — the revenue-drivers.

Divide your site into these 2 types of pages to boost website conversions

2. Anticipate Your Audience’s Questions

If you don’t truly understand your audience — their needs, anxieties, hopes, and challenges — it’s incredibly difficult to sell to them. When building a website, you need to anticipate your audience’s questions so you can reassure them and alleviate friction in the conversion process. If you’re unable to quickly and seamlessly field their questions, they’ll likely leave and turn to a competitor who can.

To learn what questions your audience is asking, you can analyze website tracking data, invite them to participate in a survey, or conduct interviews. Another option, which brands often overlook, is to go to directly to the voice of the customer. With call tracking and analytics, you can see which website pages are driving phone calls to your business and review conversation transcripts to identify common questions callers need answered before they decide on a purchase. You can then add those questions and answers to the page they called from to improve SEO traffic and website conversion rates.  

3. Present Your Content Intuitively

According to Andy Crestodina, 60% of websites fail to convert customers due to “findability.” Anticipating questions is one thing, but if you bury the answers on various subpages, users may never see them.

FAQs pages are a common misstep in website design. Users — especially mobile users — want to view your content with as little friction as possible. Rather than forcing them to navigate to a separate page to answer their burning questions, you should present the answers on your product or services pages in a logical flow. This will lower your bounce rates and ensure a smoother experience.

4. Support Your Product or Service with Evidence

You can write all the copy you want about the value of your product or service, but all you’re doing is feeding your audience unsubstantiated marketing claims. To truly earn their trust and sway their opinion, you need to provide either Big Evidence or Small Evidence (preferably a mixture of the two).

There are 2 types of evidence marketers can use to drive website conversions 

Many brands neglect to include small evidence — however it’s more important than people realize. As we know from basic psychology, many human decisions are based on emotion rather than fact. This makes small evidence a powerful tool. Just think about Amazon — almost half of each product page is made up of small evidence, in the form of user reviews.

5. Use This Testimonial Format

The below example is an ideal testimonial format. These 7 elements catch the reader’s eye, allow them to easily skim the content, and provide credibility.

This testimonial format increases website conversions

Instead of creating a single “testimonials” page, distribute your testimonials across their relevant product pages to increase visibility.

6. Create Long Website Pages

Long website pages are proven to convert better than short pages. Think about it this way: you don’t want to prematurely stop a conversation with a potential customer. All visitors require a different amount of proof to ultimately convert, so you should provide enough evidence to sway even your most skeptical visitors. If your heat maps reveal a 75% drop-off halfway through your pages, that’s okay — if you cut this page short, you create a 100% drop-off, preventing many visitors from continuing their interactions and getting the information they need. However, don’t overcrowd your pages — ensure there’s one main focus at every scroll depth.

7. Use Powerful Call-to-Actions

According to Andy Crestodina, using first-person language on call-to-action (CTA) buttons increases conversion rates by 90%. For instance, rather than “Start Your Free Trial,” use “Start My Free Trial” on your CTA buttons. This allows the user to more easily envision themself performing the action.

In addition to using first-person language, you should also ensure your CTA buttons are specific, vivid, and answer visitors’ questions. For example, for a blog, “Subscribe” is far less effective than “Join over 5,000 readers who receive weekly marketing tips.” This language is more vivid — it shows the visitor more evidence and it describes exactly what they’d be committing to.

8. Make It Easy for Customers to Call You

When optimizing your site, it’s important to take call conversions into account as well. Make sure it’s easy for customers to find your phone number and call you — especially on mobile devices. Include a click-to-call phone number in the header and footer of each website page, so users can seamlessly engage with one of your agents to ask questions or make a purchase.

9. Track and Analyze Call Conversions

While marketers can quantify the exact number of online conversions they receive, phone calls are often a black hole. This is problematic since inbound calls are often the most valuable conversions — they convert to 10x-15x more revenue than form fills. To truly optimize your website, you need to understand the total number of conversions you’re driving — both online and over the phone — and the value of those conversions to your business. Without this full data set, you could be making uninformed decisions and missing out on revenue.

10. Test and Optimize

Website optimization is an ongoing process. Through continual A/B testing and refinement, you can gradually increase your website conversions. Heat maps, website tracking tools, and call tracking solutions are all valuable tools to help you take an informed, data-driven approach.

Check out our webinar Your 60-Minute Masterclass: Website Conversion Optimization to learn more best practices from Andy Crestodina and the DialogTech team.

Check out our 60-Minute Masterclass: Website Conversion Optimization webinar to learn more website optimization tips from Andy Crestodina and the DialogTech team.

Instantly View My On-Demand Webinar →
About the author:

Derek Andersen

Copywriter, DialogTech

Derek is a copywriter at DialogTech. He graduated from Illinois Wesleyan University with a degree in Marketing and Creative Writing. He enjoys running, playing guitar, and staying up to speed on the latest news in marketing and technology.

See more posts by Derek Andersen

Enjoying our content?

Get the latest straight to your inbox.